Update November 2018
The below article was originally published in May 2017. At this time, we were already in the process of trialling and testing formulations for our new Natural Soaps range and Skincare range.
With all of these products, we were adamant that we would not use palm oil and we are delighted to now have these PALM OIL FREE beauty products available. See here for details.
What is Palm Oil?
Palm oil is a vegetable oil, which is an edible oil that comes from the oil palm. The palms that palm oil is made from is the African oil palm (Elaeis guineensis) and the American oil palm (Elaeis oleifera).
It is predominantly used within commercial food due to:
- its stability when cooking with it (especially when it has been refined)
- it can be used within products to help make a longer shelf life
- it is cheap to produce
- the amount of oil each palm can produce is high
This increase in demand for palm oil has led to the mass plantation of oil palm trees and this in itself has led to some devastating impacts on the areas in which they are grown. ‘Palm oil by the numbers’ gives an overview of palm oil and its impact (image credit to Fix).
What is the Controversy Surrounding Palm Oil?
If you’ve read any articles in relation to palm oil, you’ve no doubt seen some horror stories. Due to the amount of oil that each palm can produce and the low costs involved in growing it, there has been an increase in cultivation of these palms. However they aren’t being grown in open spaces.
Forests within Indonesia and Malaysia are the main places where palm oil is produced (around 86%). These forests are being destroyed at an alarming rate so that oil palms can be grown in their place. So, by destroying the rainforest to grow these plantations, they are in turn destroying the natural habitat in which a diversity of wildlife and plants thrive and grow.
If you google images of pam oil plantations in Indonesia and Malaysia, you’ll see the extent to which the palm trees cover the land. From 1990 to 2010, 8.7 million acres of rainforest in Indonesia, Malaysia, and Papua New Guinea were cleared for palm plantations (Ethical Consumer, 2016)
One of the most recognised things to have been impacted by this deforestation is the destruction of land in which orangutans, elephants, rhinos and Sumatran tigers live. The forests in which these animals live are destroyed and their homes are lost.
Most of the animals which are displaced from their homes are injured or killed during the process and animals which are of medicinal interest are also more easily accessible to be sold.
Due to the unsustainable development and the high rates that forest is destroyed in Indonesia, a third of all mammals are critically endangered (Say No To Palm Oil, 2017).
If nothing is done to change how we are destroying the forests it has been found that it would be likely that species like the orangutan could become extinct in the wild within the next 5-10 years and for the Sumatran tiger, less than 3 years (Say No To Palm Oil, 2017). A horrifying thought, that these things are carried out at the expense of others.
I’ve added this at the end of this paragraph but just to show the despicable impact we are having on species. I’m going to mention what I’ve read about orangutans, it’s quite upsetting to read…… It has been found that orangutans have been found buried alive, as well as killed from machete, guns and other weapon attacks. Over the last 2 decades over 50,000 orangutans have died due to the deforestation, this is either during the process, or when they enter a village or other plantations in search of food.
It has also been found that mother orangutans have been killed by poachers and their babies have been taken to be sold as pets; used for entertainment in tourist parks; or shipped to different countries to live a life of abuse (Say No To Palm Oil, 2017).
It is not just the animals which lose their homes. The people who are indigenous to the forests also are forced out of their homes and the lives they once knew are destroyed.
There is also the impact on those that work within the plantations. In the more remote areas, children will be used within the plantation for work. People within these areas no longer have the option to work elsewhere, as the only work available is within the plantation, no longer being able to be self-sustainable.
As I’ve written above, the land which is destroyed is usually forests holding whole ecosystems, which are biodiverse.
It has been equated that for every hour that passes, around 300 football fields of rainforests are cleared to enable the plantation of palm oil (Say No To Palm Oil, 2017).
When the rainforest is destroyed, it is burnt down. These trees hold and store a mass amount of carbon, causing an increase in emissions of carbon dioxide, impacting climate change.
Palm oil mills also generate lots of waste, which can lead to pollution, damaging those downstream, especially if pesticides and fertilizers are used (people, plants and animals) (WWF, 2016).
Not just Indonesian and Malaysian rainforests are at risk
Due to the increase in demand for palm oil with a multitude of products now using it, it is looking more and more likely that West and Central Africa are going to be targeted to enable expansion for commercial plantations (Rainforest Foundation UK, 2016).
The forest which is located on the Congo Basin, is home to a huge amount of biodiversity, as is around 200 million hectares. It is also where over 40 million people get livelihood benefits, with it being estimated that there are around 500,000 indigenous forest people, which inhabit the forests. However, even though this area benefits humans, animals and plants alike, the governments which control these areas are welcoming those with opportunities of developing plantations within the area (Rainforest Foundation UK, 2016). If this is pushed forward, similar outcomes to that of what have occurred in Malaysia and Indonesia will most likely occur here. Especially if it is not controlled.
Could What Happened with Rubber Plantations, Happen with Oil Palm?
In Malaysia, the government lobbied (successfully) for rubber plantations to be classified as “forest” by the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO).
This means that these areas are counted as part of the forest and, therefore, it is more difficult to distinguish how much of the original forest remains - developers can just convert the original forest to rubber plantations without it affecting statistics. This does, however, reduce the biodiversity of the forest.
There is a concern that this may also happen with oil palms (WWF, 2016).
What is Sustainable Palm Oil?
Looking back at ‘Palm oil by the numbers’, you may have noticed the figure that says only 17% of palm oil production worldwide is actually sustainable. That’s a scary figure in itself, meaning that 83% of palm oil produced is not sustainable.
So, what does sustainable mean?
You may already have heard of sustainable fishing, crop growth etc. and this includes the production of palm oil.
Sustainable is defined as “conserving an ecological balance by avoiding depletion of natural resources” (Oxford Dictionary). From what I’ve written above and the figure from ‘Palm oil by the numbers’ showing that only 17% of palm oil is sustainable, it just shows that if we don’t do anything about it, we are going to completely wipe out ecosystems which are of great importance, destroying the lives of many.
In all honesty, if the figure comes out that 83% of palm oil is not sustainable, chances are that most of the products you’re using which contain palm oil are not going to be sustainable. If they are, the company would promote this information to us as consumers.
Sustainable palm oil, is where the aim is to produce palm oil that does not cause deforestation or harm to the people in the areas.
In 2004, there was the formation of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), a scheme which is in place to prevent deforestation from this industry. When buying products which contain palm oil it is essential that you purchase products which have the RSPO label. This indicates that the palm oil has been produced in a social and environmentally responsible way.
Although no primary forest or areas which contain significant concentrations of biodiversity, fragile ecosystems, or areas which are fundamental to meeting basic of traditional cultural needs to local communities can be cleared (RSPO, 2017), it is not forbidden that other areas of forest cannot be removed. You can read more about RSPO here.
How is Palm Oil Made and Used?
Here is a simple and quick example of the process of how palm oil is produced and sent to manufacturers to be used within products.
(Image credit to Fix)
Not Just Known as Palm Oil?
There is so much controversy surrounding palm oil, that in some cases companies may not have it labelled as palm oil. Similar to sugar and its multitude of names (high-fructose corn syrup, sucrose, corn syrup solids, fructose syrups, brown sugar and dextrose, useful tip – anything that ends in –ose is a sugar), palm oil also has a number of different names which you may find on your products’ labels instead of just palm oil.
I’m going to give you a short list of different names that palm oil and its derivatives comes hidden under, so if you’re ever reading the label and see one of these come up, you know it contains palm oil:
- Vegetable oil
- Vegetable fat
- Palm Kernel
- Palm Kernel Oil
- Palm Fruit Oil
- Stearic Acid
- Palmitic Acid
- Sodium Laureth Sulfate
- Sodium Lauryl Lactylate/Sulphate
- Palmityl Alcohol
Another website which has a longer list of names is: Palm Oil Investigations: Palm oil – the hidden ingredient with over 200 names
In December 2015, an EU law came into place which stated that the type of oil which is used within food products must be stated clearly on the label, however within other products that are not food it does not need to be clearly stated.
Which Products Contain Palm Oil?
Around 50% of the products that we use on a daily basis actually contain palm oil, including:
- Ice cream
and even though above I said that it was used within foods, due to its cheapness and stability, it is also found in:
- cleaning products
- washing detergents
- body and hair washes
This WWF link has interactive images on why different products contain palm oil, which you can access here.
(Image credit to Fix)
When looking at the ingredients, if one of the names from above come up within the list check to see if it is using sustainable palm oil. ‘Finding sustainable palm oil’ shows what you should look out for and how to find out if products are using sustainable palm oil.
If you are going to purchase products which contain palm oil, it is important to try and ensure that they are RSPO certified. It is important that we strive as consumers to encourage companies to use sustainable palm oil within their products. Ethical Consumer Magazine released an issue which talks about the impact of palm oil, which you can have a look at here (Issue 165 March/April 2017).
Rainforest Foundation UK and the Ethical Consumer Magazine joined up in 2015 to write up about different products which use sustainable and unsustainable products – you can read more here.‘Say No To Palm Oil’ also have a page which talks about actions we can also take to try and make a difference which you can access here.
Ethical Consumer. (2016). Rainforest Foundation and Ethical Consumer Palm Oil Campaign.Available here.
WWF. (2016). Palm oil & forest conversion. Available here.
Say No To Palm Oil. (2017). Palm Oil. Available here.
RSPO. (2017). Sustainable palm oil. Available here.
About Lucy Bee Limited
Lucy Bee is concerned with Fair Trade, ethical and sustainable living, recycling and eating close to nature with additive free products for health.
Members of the Lucy Bee team are not medically trained and can only offer their best advice. Any information provided by us is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent disease.
Please note you should always refer your health queries to a qualified medical practitioner.
Daisy, MSc PGDip ANutr, is a Registered Associate Nutritionist with a Master's Degree in Public Health Nutrition, and a Post Graduate Diploma in Eating Disorders and Clinical Nutrition, both of which are Association for Nutrition (AFN) accredited. She, also, has a BSc degree in Psychology and Cognitive Neuroscience; and has completed an AFN accredited Diet Specialist Nutrition course.
Daisy has worked for an NHS funded project, the Diabetes Prevention Programme; and shadowed a nutritionist in Harley Street.
About Lucy Bee Limited
Members of the Lucy Bee team are not medically trained and can only offer their best advice. Any information provided by us is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent disease. Please note you should always refer your health queries to a qualified medical practitioner.
Lucy Bee is a lifestyle brand selling food, skincare and soap products all completely free from palm oil and with minimal use of plastic. Lucy Bee is concerned with Fair Trade, organic, ethical and sustainable living, recycling and empowering people to make informed choices and select quality, natural products for their food and their skin.